The Recorder

James Thomson Callender (1757 or 1758–1803)

James Thomson Callender was a partisan journalist known for attacking Federalists but also his one-time Republican ally, Thomas Jefferson. Born in Scotland, Callender was a Scottish nationalist who published pamphlets critical of the British government. When a warrant was issued for his arrest, he fled first to Ireland and then, in 1793, to Philadelphia. There he wrote newspaper items critical of the administrations of George Washington and John Adams and a pamphlet that exposed an extramarital affair by Alexander Hamilton. After the passage of the Alien and Sedition Acts in 1798, Callender, who had moved to Richmond by this time, published another pamphlet critical of President Adams. In the spring of 1800 he was tried and convicted of sedition in Richmond and served nine months in jail. When Jefferson was elected president in 1801, Callender expected to be rewarded with a political position. When he was not, he turned on his former ally, accusing the president of having fathered children by his enslaved servant Sally Hemings. Callender purchased part ownership of the Richmond Recorder newspaper, but quit after quarrels with his coeditor. He accidentally drowned in the James River in 1803. MORE...

 

Early Years

Callender was born in Scotland in either 1757 or 1758, but the place and date of his birth and the names of his parents are not known. He may have been the son of a tobacco merchant, and he was probably orphaned at an early age. Callender obtained a basic classical education and a strong dose of Calvinism. In 1782 he became a clerk in a public office in Edinburgh, where he learned firsthand about corruption and misuse of influence. Callender became a registered messenger at arms in 1787. He entered Edinburgh's literary circle through the publication of several anonymous pamphlets and poems, including Deformities of Dr. Samuel Johnson (1782), a pamphlet critical of the famed author and disparager of Scotland. The work showed Callender to be both a well-read man and a slashing writer.

An intense Scottish nationalist, Callender published a series of pamphlets that brought him into conflict with the authorities. His Political Progress of Britain (Part First) (1792) led to an interrogation late in December 1792, and early in January a warrant was issued for his arrest. After he failed to attend the court proceedings, Callender was declared an outlaw and went into hiding in Dublin, where he associated with leaders of the Society of United Irishmen. In spring 1793, leaving his wife (whose name is unknown) and three children in Scotland, he immigrated to the United States and arrived in May 1793.

Rabble-Rousing Republican

Through his Irish connections, Callender obtained work in Matthew Carey's Philadelphia bookstore and ultimately became the congressional reporter for Andrew Brown's Philadelphia Gazette, a position he helduntil the spring of 1796. In a period of intensifying partisanship, Callender became intimately associated with the emerging Republican Party and earned the enmity of leading Federalists. Between 1794 and 1798 he contributed anonymous news articles and columns critical of the administrations of George Washington and John Adams to the Philadelphia Aurora. Besides republishing his earlier works, Callender produced new pamphlets attacking the policies of the American government, especially those regarding trade, as subordinating American interests to those of the British government. Callender and other radical émigrés shared an Anglophobia and an urban economic nationalism. They rejected not only Alexander Hamilton's fiscal program but also the agrarianism of the Virginia planters of their own party. Callender's reputation was further enhanced by William Cobbett's virulent attacks on his work in Porcupine's Gazette, one of Philadelphia's Federalist newspapers. During this time Callender's wife and children joined him in Philadelphia, and a fourth child was born before May 1796.

Callender achieved his first great notoriety by reporting on Hamilton's adulterous affair with Maria Reynolds in the History of the United States for 1796 (1797). Life in Philadelphia eventually became hazardous for the outspoken journalist. In addition to the recurrence of yellow fever, threats to his personal safety, and mounting personal financial problems, Callender's livelihood was threatened by the adoption of the Alien and Sedition Acts, which sought to muzzle political criticism of the government. By the summer of 1798 his wife had died. Coming under increasing attack for his activities and hoping to remove any danger that he might be deported once the Naturalization and Alien Acts of 1798 passed, Callender on June 4 petitioned for American citizenship. The following month he abandoned Philadelphia for the relative safety of Virginia, leaving his children behind.

For several months Callender stayed at the Loudoun County plantation of Senator Stevens Thomson Mason, and then in May 1799 he moved to Richmond. He contributed articles critical of the Adams administration to the leading local Republican newspaper, the Richmond Examiner, and published his most famous work, The Prospect Before Us, Volume 1 (1800), a highly partisan political history of the 1790s with a decidedly southern emphasis and numerous insulting remarks about Adams and his policies. On May 24, 1800, the U.S. District Court grand jury indicted Callender for sedition, and after a sensational trial presided over by U.S. Supreme Court associate justice Samuel Chase, Callender was convicted on June 3, 1800, sentenced to jail for nine months, and fined $200. His trial and imprisonment made Callender a political martyr. Republicans raised money for his relief, and the Republican press throughout the country condemned Chase's partisan behavior during the trial and made suppression of the press an issue in that year's presidential election. While incarcerated Callender wrote and published two more volumes of The Prospect Before Us.

Released from jail, Callender resumed his activities with renewed enthusiasm, much to the dismay of moderate Republicans. Because Thomas Jefferson had covertly supported his journalistic efforts in Philadelphia and openly encouraged him in Virginia, Callender viewed him as a patron whose obligations were enhanced by his incarceration and sufferings. Not surprisingly, after Jefferson became president in March 1801 Callender expected a pardon and immediate remission of his fine, and he also insisted on being appointed postmaster of Richmond. Jefferson retroactively pardoned Callender after his release but failed to bestow a government job.

Later Years

Bitterly disappointed, Callender severed his ties with the Richmond Examiner and gravitated to the Richmond Recorder: or, Lady's and Gentleman's Miscellany, a newspaper in which he acquired a part interest in February 1802. Much to the surprise and chagrin of his former allies, he repudiated the Republicans and openly criticized the Jefferson administration with the same strong invective he had formerly directed toward the Federalists. Beginning in September 1802 Callender published a series of articles in the Recorder accusing Jefferson of maintaining a long relationship with his slave Sally Hemings and fathering her children. Jeffersonians at the time and many subsequent Jefferson biographers discounted Callender's assertions and emphasized his partisan bias, but recent scholarship suggests that even though vengeance certainly prompted Callender to publish his critical articles about Jefferson's personal life, he was probably reporting accurately.

Circulation of the Recorder increased briefly, spurred by reports of Callender's public altercation in December 1802 with George Hay, the Republican attorney who had represented him at his sedition trial, but sustained publishing success proved as elusive as ever. Amid threats of violence from Richmond Republicans, Callender quarreled with his coeditor over money and, facing an uncertain economic future, withdrew from the Richmond Recorder in April 1803. Callender, who often found solace in drink during periods of crisis, drowned in the James River at Richmond on July 17, 1803, and was buried in a local church cemetery later the same day. A coroner's jury returned a verdict of accidental drowning as a result of intoxication.

Major Works

  • Deformities of Dr. Samuel Johnson (1782)
  • Political Progress of Britain (Part First) (1792)
  • History of the United States for 1796 (1797)
  • The Prospect Before Us, Volumes 1–3 (1800–1801)

Time Line

  • 1757 or 1758 - James Thomson Callender is born in Scotland.
  • 1782 - James Thomson Callender becomes a clerk in a public office in Edinburgh, Scotland.
  • 1787 - James Thomson Callender becomes a registered messenger at arms in Edinburgh, Scotland.
  • Late December 1792 - After the publication of a pamphlet critical of the British government, James Thomson Callender is interrogated.
  • Early January 1793 - After he criticized the British government in print, a warrant is issued for James Thomson Callender's arrest.
  • Spring 1793–Spring 1796 - James Thomson Callender works in Matthew Carey's Philadelphia bookstore.
  • May 1793 - On the run from British authorities, James Thomson Callender immigrates to the United States.
  • 1794–1798 - James Thomson Callender contributes anonymous items critical of George Washington and John Adams to the Philadelphia Aurora.
  • Summer 1798 - By this time the wife of James Thomson Callender has died.
  • 1798 - Congress passes the Alien and Sedition Acts, a series of laws that increased the residency requirement for American citizenship, gave the president authority to deport or imprison illegal aliens, and restricted speech against the government.
  • June 4, 1798 - James Thomson Callender, a native of Scotland, petitions for United States citizenship.
  • May 1799 - James Thomson Callender moves to Richmond, where he writes newspaper articles critical of Federalists.
  • May 24, 1800 - A U.S. District Court grand jury indicts James Thomson Callender for sedition.
  • June 3, 1800 - James Thomson Callender is convicted of sedition in the U.S. District Court in Richmond. He is sentenced to nine months in jail and fined $200.
  • March 1801 - James Thomson Callender is embittered when he does not receive a political appointment by the newly elected president, Thomas Jefferson.
  • February 1802 - James Thomson Callender acquires a part interest in the Richmond Recorder.
  • September 1, 1802 - In "The President, Again," published on September 1, 1802, in the Richmond Recorder, a Federalist newspaper, James Thomson Callender turns on his former patron, accusing President Thomas Jefferson of having fathered children with a slave named Sally (presumably Sally Hemings).
  • December 1802 - James Thomson Callender and his lawyer, George Hay, have a public altercation in Richmond.
  • April 1803 - Amidst quarrels with his coeditor, James Thomson Callender quits the Richmond Recorder.
  • July 17, 1803 - James Thomson Callender accidentally drowns in the James River.

References

Further Reading
Ridgway, Whitman H. "Callender, James Thomson." In the Dictionary of Virginia Biography, Vol. 2, edited by Sara B. Bearss et al., 520–522. Richmond: Library of Virginia, 2001.
Cite This Entry
  • APA Citation:

    Ridgway, W. H., & the Dictionary of Virginia Biography. James Thomson Callender (1757 or 1758–1803). (2016, August 22). In Encyclopedia Virginia. Retrieved from http://www.EncyclopediaVirginia.org/Callender_James_Thomson_1757_or_1758-1803.

  • MLA Citation:

    Ridgway, Whitman H. and the Dictionary of Virginia Biography. "James Thomson Callender (1757 or 1758–1803)." Encyclopedia Virginia. Virginia Foundation for the Humanities, 22 Aug. 2016. Web. READ_DATE.

First published: April 20, 2016 | Last modified: August 22, 2016


Contributed by Whitman H. Ridgway and the Dictionary of Virginia Biography