Martha Haines Butt

Martha Haines Butt (1833–1871)

Martha Haines Butt was a novelist, poet, and essayist who in 1853 became one of five southern women to respond to Harriet Beecher Stowe's antislavery novel Uncle Tom's Cabin (1852) with a novel of her own. Antifanaticism: A Tale of the South (1853) defended slavery as moral and Christian, but it never achieved the critical or popular success that Stowe or even the other rebuttals received. A Norfolk native, Butt continued to write, contributing to both regional and national magazines. She championed women's intellectual engagement but criticized efforts on behalf of women's rights, generally affirming the traditional role of women. Late in her life, however, she became involved in the woman suffrage movement and served as vice president of the Virginia State Woman Suffrage Association in 1870. Butt died of pneumonia a year later. MORE...

 

Butt was born on November 22, 1833, in Norfolk, the daughter of Francis Butt and Mary Ann Morriss Butt, a milliner. Between about 1847 and 1850 she attended Patapsco Female Institute in Ellicott's Mills, Howard County, Maryland. In April 1850 Butt's essay on the "Influence of Music" appeared in the Patapsco Young Ladies' Magazine.

Butt made her mark early as a writer. Her most ambitious work was published in Philadelphia just a few years after she left school. Entitled Antifanaticism: A Tale of the South, the book was one of five novels that southern women wrote in response to Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin. Although Butt's novel did not achieve the critical or popular success of other rebuttals of Uncle Tom's Cabin, it did contain key elements of the southern literary nationalism that was beginning to emerge in the 1850s. In the preface Butt described herself as "a warm-hearted Virginian" determined to defend southern society against Stowe's charge that the cruelty of slavery had undermined the region's morality. Through the story of life on a fictional cotton plantation, Butt portrayed slavery as a benevolent, Christianizing institution. She repeatedly emphasized that slaves were better off than servants in the North and that they did not want freedom. Butt promoted sectional reconciliation by attempting to persuade her readers that if northerners traveled to the South they would come to agree with southern slave owners and adopt proslavery attitudes. The enthralled northern visitors to her fictional plantation became supporters of slavery, and the planter's children married northerners.

Despite the significance of Antifanaticism as a political statement, the heart of Butt's literary career was not her one novel but her plentiful poems, stories, and essays. During the 1850s she contributed short pieces to national and regional periodicals, including Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper and Godey's Magazine and Lady's Book. Butt also wrote two poems for William S. Forrest's promotional compendium, Historical and Descriptive Sketches of Norfolk and Vicinity (1853). At the time women's contributions to periodicals were seldom signed, making it impossible to identify all of her publications, but some of her articles appeared under her name or initials. In 1855 Butt became a contributing editor of two short-lived periodicals published by women, the Kaleidoscope, a weekly established by Rebecca Brodnax Hicks in Petersburg, and the Ladies' Repository, a monthly published in Richmond by a woman known only by the pseudonym Lillie Linden. When controversy arose about the Ladies' Repository, apparently concerning its financial practices, Butt publicly severed all connection with the journal. In 1859 Harrisburg Female College, in Pennsylvania, awarded her an A.M. (Artium Magister).

In 1860 Butt published her second book, a collection of short works entitled The Leisure Moments of Miss Martha Haines Butt, A.M. Through moral tales, poems, and personal musings she championed such values as Christian benevolence, companionate marriage, and thrift. Butt also pointedly criticized society's preoccupation with fashion, gossip, status, and wealth, but she steered clear of the subject of slavery. In Leisure Moments her identity as a Virginian was clearly evident in her meditation on Norfolk's yellow fever epidemic of 1855 and in her paeans to the works of Virginia sculptors William Randolph Barbee and Alexander Galt. By the time this work was published Butt had moved to New York and gained a national reputation not only as an engaging writer of prescriptive verse and prose but also as a beautiful, graceful woman who always dressed with great style.

On July 6, 1865, at Christ Church in Norfolk Butt married Nathan Ives Bennett, of Bridgeport, Connecticut, who was then working as a clerk in the quartermaster department in Norfolk. They lived later in Hartford, Connecticut, and in New York City. Shortly after her marriage she published her final book, Pastimes with My Little Friends (1866), a collection of stories for children.

In 1870 Butt became active in two new fields. Although long a forceful advocate of intellectual pursuits for women, in both the Kaleidoscope and Leisure Moments she had criticized women's rights activists and defended women's traditional role exerting influence primarily through the home. Adopting a new perspective, Butt became a vice president of the Virginia State Woman Suffrage Association at its founding in May 1870. That autumn she announced her intention to attend lectures at the Woman's Medical College of the New York Infirmary, Elizabeth Blackwell's pioneering medical school for women that emphasized preventive medicine, clinical work, and service to the poor.

Developing pneumonia not long thereafter, Martha Haines Butt Bennett died on February 9, 1871, at the Grand Central Hotel in New York City. She was buried in Norfolk.

Major Works

  • Antifanaticism: A Tale of the South (1853)
  • The Leisure Moments of Miss Martha Haines Butt, A.M. (1860)
  • Pastimes with My Little Friends (1866)

Time Line

  • November 22, 1833 - Martha Haines Butt is born in Norfolk.
  • 1847 - On or about this year, Martha Haines Butt enters Patapsco Female Institute in Ellicott's Mills, Howard County, Maryland. She will receive an AM degree in 1850.
  • April 1850 - Martha Haines Butt's essay on the "Influence of Music" appears in the Patapsco Young Ladies' Magazine.
  • 1853 - Martha Haines Butt's novel Antifanaticism: A Tale of the South is published as a defense of slavery against the accusations contained in Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin (1852).
  • 1855 - Martha Haines Butt becomes a contributing editor of two short-lived periodicals published by women, the Kaleidoscope, a weekly established by Rebecca Brodnax Hicks in Petersburg, and the Ladies' Repository, a monthly published in Richmond by a woman known only by the pseudonym Lillie Linden.
  • July 6, 1865 - Martha Haines Butt marries Nathan Ives Bennett at Christ Church in Norfolk. Bennett is a Connecticut native working as a clerk in the quartermaster department in Norfolk.
  • May 1870 - Despite having previously criticized women's rights activists, Martha Haines Butt becomes vice president of the newly established Virginia State Woman Suffrage Association.
  • February 9, 1871 - Martha Haines Butt dies of pneumonia at the Grand Central hotel in New York City. She is buried in Norfolk.
Further Reading
Van Zelm, Antoinette G. "Martha Haines Butt." In Dictionary of Virginia Biography, vol. 2, edited by Sara B. Bearss, 443–444. Richmond: Library of Virginia, 2001.
Cite This Entry
  • APA Citation:

    van Zelm, A. G., & the Dictionary of Virginia Biography. Martha Haines Butt (1833–1871). (2013, September 23). In Encyclopedia Virginia. Retrieved from http://www.EncyclopediaVirginia.org/Butt_Martha_Haines_1833-1871.

  • MLA Citation:

    van Zelm, Antoinette G. and the Dictionary of Virginia Biography. "Martha Haines Butt (1833–1871)." Encyclopedia Virginia. Virginia Foundation for the Humanities, 23 Sep. 2013. Web. READ_DATE.

First published: June 8, 2009 | Last modified: September 23, 2013